top of page

The Ultimate Guide to Creating a Monthly Donor Program

A monthly donor program is a valuable strategy for securing reliable and recurring fundraising income. While one-time donations can provide an initial boost, establishing a monthly donor program can create a dependable source of funds that enables organizations to plan for the future. By implementing an effective strategy, you can create a successful program that ensures the long-term sustainability of your nonprofit, allowing you to continue carrying out your mission and making a positive impact in the community. Here’s how to create and manage an effective monthly donor program for your organization.

Understand Your Audience and Goals.

Before you launch your monthly donor program, it's important to understand who your target audience is. Identify current supporters and their giving habits and potential donors interested in contributing a monthly donation. It's also helpful to have a clear idea of your goals for the program - how many donors do you want within a certain amount of time? What do you hope to achieve through the program? How much money do you need to raise each month? What are your priorities for spending the funds raised? Understanding these factors will help you create an effective strategy for creating and managing your monthly donor program. Here are some steps to help you determine the goals for your monthly giving program:

Review your financial needs: The first step in setting goals for your monthly giving program is to review your organization's financial needs. Consider the amount of money you need to raise each year to cover your expenses and fund your programs. Determine how much you would like to come from your monthly giving program.

Analyze your donor base: Review and determine your monthly giving prospects (see next step).

Determine the acquisition cost: Calculate the cost of acquiring a monthly donor, including marketing or communication expenses. This will help you determine how much money you need to raise to cover these costs.

Set realistic goals: Set goals based on your financial needs analysis, donor base, and acquisition cost that are realistic. Sett both short-term and long-term goals, such as increasing the number of monthly donors by a certain percentage each year.

Monitor and adjust: Once you have set your goals, monitor your progress regularly and adjust your strategies as needed. Use data to track your monthly giving program’s success and adjust as needed.

Remember that the goals for your monthly giving program should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART). Setting realistic goals and regularly monitoring your progress can create a successful monthly giving program that helps your organization achieve its mission.

Identify Prospects and Create Donor Personas.

Identifying potential monthly donors for your nonprofit organization is essential in creating a successful monthly donor program. Here are some strategies to help you determine who would make an excellent monthly donor prospect:

Analyze your donor database: Start by analyzing your current donor database to identify individuals who have donated multiple times or given more significant gifts. These donors are more likely to be interested in supporting your organization regularly.

Use Identity-Based Targeting: Consider the demographics of your existing donors and target audiences. What are their habits, interests, and behaviours? Use this information to build donor personas, which will help you create more targeted and engaging messaging.

Identify individuals with a history of giving to similar causes: Look for individuals with a history of giving to other organizations that align with your mission. These individuals are more likely to be interested in supporting your organization every month.

Utilize online tools: There are several online tools, such as WealthEngine and DonorSearch, that can help you identify potential monthly donors based on their giving history, wealth, and other relevant data.

Look for engagement and loyalty: Consider individuals who have engaged with your organization in other ways, such as attending events, volunteering, or following you on social media. These individuals are likelier to be loyal supporters and interested in making recurring gifts.

Design an Engaging Monthly Gift Program.

Once you know your target audience and have set your goals, it’s time to create an engaging monthly gift program. Here are some tips to help you create a strong case for support:

Focus on and show the impact: Explain why monthly donations are essential to achieving that mission and how they will help make a lasting impact. Use data and statistics to show the effects of monthly contributions. Share the number of people served, the outcomes achieved, and the progress toward the organization's goals.

Share stories: Share stories of the people or communities that benefit from your programs and services. Use real-life examples to illustrate the impact of monthly donations and show how they make a difference in people's lives.

Be specific: Be specific about how monthly donations will be used and how they will help the organization achieve its goals. Share specific examples of programs or services that monthly donations will support.

Offer a personal connection: Provide a personal link to your organization's work. Share your story or the story of a staff member, donor or volunteer to show why the cause is important to you and why monthly donations are critical to achieving the organization's mission.

Make it easy to give: Make it easy for donors to sign up for monthly giving. Provide clear instructions on how to sign up, and make sure the process is straightforward.

Remember, creating a compelling case for support is an ongoing process. Regularly evaluate your messaging and make adjustments as needed. By emphasizing the impact of monthly donations and the importance of ongoing support, you can create a strong case for support that resonates with your donors and encourages them to give regularly.

Determine the giving levels:

Decide on the different giving levels for your monthly donor program. Consider offering a range of options so donors can choose the most comfortable level. Ensure to provide tangible benefits at each level to show donors how their support makes a difference. Here are some tips to help you determine the giving levels for your monthly donor campaign:

Review your current donor base: Review your existing donor base and consider the average gift size of your monthly donors. This will give you a starting point for determining giving levels.

Research other organizations: Research other organizations in your field and review their monthly giving programs. Consider the giving levels and benefits they offer at each level. This can help you determine what is appropriate for your organization.

Offer various options: Consider offering various giving levels to accommodate donors at different levels of giving capacity. This can include lower-level options for donors just starting out and higher-level options for those who can provide more.

Provide tangible benefits: Consider providing benefits at each giving level to encourage donors to give at higher levels. This can include exclusive content, early access to events, or other benefits that demonstrate the impact of their support.

Use donor feedback: Solicit feedback from your current donors about your giving levels and the benefits you provide. Use this feedback to adjust your giving levels and benefits as needed.

Regularly evaluate your program and make adjustments as needed to ensure that it is meeting the needs of your donors and helping you achieve your fundraising goals.

Craft Effective Promotional Messages and Campaigns.

Once you’ve established your program, you want to ensure you get the word out via all your communication channels. Here are some ideas to help you promote your monthly giving program:

Create a dedicated landing page: Make it easy for supporters to sign up by creating a dedicated recurring giving page on your website. Ensure the page is easy to find and includes clear instructions on signing up.

Highlight the impact on social media: Share stories and testimonials from your current monthly donors about the impact of their contributions. Use statistics and infographics to show how monthly donations add up over time and make a significant difference.

Consider boosting: Nonprofits can utilize social media boosting or ads to promote their monthly giving campaign to a wider audience. Targeted ads can reach potential donors who may not have heard about their organization or monthly giving program.

Use email marketing: Use your email newsletter to promote your monthly giving program, highlighting the benefits and impact of monthly donations. Consider sending a dedicated email campaign to encourage supporters to sign up.

Offer exclusive benefits: Consider offering exclusive benefits to monthly donors, such as early access to events, behind-the-scenes tours, or personalized updates from program staff.

Partner with local businesses: Partner with local businesses to promote your monthly giving program. For example, a coffee shop might offer a free drink to customers who sign up to give monthly.

Be creative, experiment with different approaches, and regularly communicate the impact of your monthly donors to keep them engaged and committed to your cause.

Offer Recognition to Show Appreciation for Donors’ Support.

There are several ways to acknowledge donors and demonstrate your gratitude that will help foster loyalty between you and the donor. Make sure to recognize each gift promptly and provide regular updates on the impact of their support. Here are some creative ways to show your appreciation for your monthly donors:

Personalized video messages: Create a video message from staff, volunteers, or program participants to thank your monthly donors. This can be a powerful way to show their contributions' impact and demonstrate their ongoing support's importance.

Personalized notes: Send personalized letters, cards or emails to each of your monthly donors to thank them for their ongoing support. Consider including updates on the impact of their contributions and highlighting the difference they are making in the community.

Recognition on your website: Try recognizing your monthly donors on your website. This can include a special page highlighting the names and photos of your monthly donors, as well as the impact of their contributions.

Special events: Host a special event for your monthly donors to show appreciation. Events can include exclusive tours, networking events, receptions, or invitations to your annual fundraising event.

Surprise gifts: Surprise your monthly donors with a small gift to show appreciation. This can include a branded t-shirt, a tote bag, or other items that demonstrate the impact of their support.

Social media shoutouts: Use your social media channels to recognize and thank your monthly donors. Consider creating unique graphics or videos to show the impact of their contributions and highlight their support.

Regularly evaluate your stewardship strategies and adjust as needed to ensure your monthly donors feel appreciated and valued. By showing your appreciation in creative and meaningful ways, you can build strong relationships with your monthly donors and help ensure the long-term success of your monthly giving program.

Creating a monthly donor program can be valuable for nonprofits to generate consistent support and plan for the future. By following these tips, you can create a program that resonates with your donors and helps your organization achieve its goals.


bottom of page